“Now is not the time to pine for the days of agreeable politics. In recent decades, the US has gone through radical political and cultural transformations that are making the country progressively ungovernable. Any kind of national election from here on out will be viewed as illegitimate by the losing side due to the perceived high stakes of these affairs. No longer do America’s partisan coalitions treat each other as respectable competitors, but rather as existential threats that must be vanquished at the ballot box. As America’s social fabric continues withering and polarization intensifies, it’s only a matter of time before this kind of tension turns violent.” Walter Williams
I opened this post with an exceptionally long quote by an American economist that likely few people know about; I did so because this quote summed up very well where we are now. Williams died soon after the 2020 presidential election which eerily represented what he described. It was also uncharacteristic of a man who was such a positive and forward-thinking force but who so clearly described the prevailing nihilism. What began as a professed campaign by the Democratic Party to heal the divide Williams described ended in its own demise for its administration’s failure to not only do what it promised, but to make it even worse.
Now as most of my readers know, I’m not a Trump fan and have never voted for him; I do understand why some of my fellow libertarians did so as I understand those that didn’t, but what we all have to understand is that he is doing what he said he would do, so why anyone is surprised about this is odd. Further, one of his character traits is also to say sensational and headline grabbing radical stuff, what I call “Flash Bang Politics”. A “flash bang” is slang for a non-lethal but loud and bright light grenade whose purpose is to disorient and distract people.
Radical reforms are rapid political, social, and economic changes that are fundamentally transformative. Such reforms are often championed by what political pundits call “Populism”, an approach that appeals to ordinary people who feel that their concerns are disregarded by established elite groups; MAGA is a populist movement, and contrary to what many people think, can’t be by definition positioned in the left-right political spectrum that pervades the comfort zone of mass media analyses and narratives. Further, populism has no guaranteed results or where it will lead, as it’s a very “fluid situation”.
Most intelligent political scientists understand what populism is and accept the fact that such movements can’t be defined in any politically orthodox way because they arise historically in so many different contexts that each needs to be understood in its own time and place; simply identifying MAGA as a right wing or Donald Trump phenomenon shows a lack of political intelligence that often leads to the demise of its critics, such as happened to the Democratic Party in the 2024 election, and inexplicably continues and likely will do so throughout this administration.
Take for example Trump’s recent proposal to take over Gaza. On face value I found this to be not only a very stupid idea considering his promise to avoid US involvement in foreign conflicts that have historically caused us so much pain, but beyond the realm of a realistic solution; but then I remembered who he is, so now I think this is just more flash bang…or at least I hope so. Maybe it will wake-up the Saudi regime whose existential enemy is Iran who could very well grow back like the cancer it is in a region the Saudis view as theirs, but hope is not a plan.
An example of how populism can sometimes cause reform that is contrary to intent is Trump’s proposal to end birth right citizenship. The understanding of the constitution’s definition of citizenship has always been inclusive of this right, although admittedly there’s a case for interpretation, but why throw a flash bang at this which only distracts from the desperately needed enforcement of our immigration laws? I am hopeful that this will not be an issue for his administration to die on the hill for.
What is heartening to see in this populist regime is its protection of women’s rights in the arena of sports; how anyone can support such a stupid idea as having biological men compete against women reminds me of George Orwell’s quote that “Some ideas are so stupid that only intellectuals believe them.” The same goes for this racist and sexist fabrication known as DEI; to actually use bigotry as a metric in evaluating human beings is beyond stupid, its evil.
What this populist movement consistently promised was to address inflation; the first place to start is effectively attacking the source, which is the US Treasury’s and the Federal Reserve’s policies of monetary and fiscal mismanagement. Inflation has not gone away, it’s only hiding behind the squawk about interest rates and some strange fixation with a 2% inflation rate; that doesn’t reduce the inflated costs that have eviscerated American pocketbooks, and tariffs will only make things worse. Maybe the tariff threats as in the case with Mexico and Canada have been nothing more than flash bangs that got their attention, but they aren’t going to work with the 800 pound gorilla in trade as China will likely just laugh and retaliate as they care little for what it will do to their people. Tariffs are a tax, which is a flash bang that detracts from the goal of tax and inflation reduction.
The other big MAGA promise involves energy, which affects just about every economic activity. The Green New Deal has been exposed as little more than pork barrel politics that sacrifices economic stability and individual welfare as an ideology; renewable energy on face value is a great idea, and hopefully as we become more technologically intelligent will become plausible, but at this point it is unreliable, resource-intensive, and environmentally destructive in material extraction. Further, energy demand is increasing exponentially so we need every source available if we are to progress, grow and provide economic opportunities.
In the long run populism often evolves into other than why it arose to begin with; what we don’t know yet is where MAGA will lead, but what we do know is that four years is its political horizon to deliver on its promises or to die on its failures to do so. It is important to track what it actually accomplishes more than what it promises, especially when led by a flash bang politician. More to come…for four more years…maybe longer!
