“Anything bad I do isn’t my fault, and everything mediocre I do is brilliant, and whatever I say about myself is real! Socialism is the mindset of a child.” Alice Smith
Alice Smith is a writer and social commentator; while there’s no record of Adam Smith having any children, she claims to be his great-great-great-granddaughter. I don’t know enough to comment on that but find that she is a very insightful writer who gets to the essence of an issue with reason and humor, and the opening quote is a good example.
Most legacy and social media report that many people wonder where all this support for socialism suddenly came from; it comes from childish ignorance that parents will not always be there to provide everything on demand, and it was not sudden. This arrested development causes a fear of reality due to the lack of life skills to cope with it. There is a very basic psychological proverb that “Beneath anger is always fear.”, and it is fear that causes an unhealthy attraction, if not addiction, to ideologies, and the more dogmatic the better. Bertrand Russell put it another way, “Much that passes as idealism is disguised hatred or disguised love of power.”
We should not be surprised about the irrational hatred focused on anyone who disagrees with socialists who refuse to listen to or even allow a contrary idea expressed; the possibility that such ideas might be valid threatens their worldview, and they will hate you for it. It is this hate that exposes the inherent fear in socialism, which is used to justify all sorts of irrational behavior; this emotional immaturity, excluding physical or mental impairment, comes from a lack of education in basic life skills engendering a sense of entitlement, and an inability to handle whatever conflicts with their behavior or beliefs. We would normally see such behavior in a spoiled child…except we’re talking about adults.
Socialism is about a frightened child who doesn’t want to grow up, who wants to replace their parents with the state who will provide free stuff like education, food, shelter and whatever those who have earned these things have. Assuming this is a matter of education is only partially correct as it goes much deeper than that; this is a social issue of simple old fashion family upbringing, engendering respect, civil behavior, self-reliance, responsibility, accountability and commonsense, none of which comes with a diploma. Thomas Sowell insightfully observed that “The problem isn’t that Johnny can’t read. The problem isn’t even that Johnny can’t think. The problem is that Johnny does not know what thinking is; he confuses it with feeling.”
This basic human societal function we call “raising” children means bringing them out of the ignorance of childhood so they have the life skills to not just survive, but flourish; a society that is built on such principles creates an environment amenable to liberty, so essential for human development, and avoids dependency created by entitlement. It provides children with the tools to be free from the ignorance that creates problems like poverty, conflict, emotional distress, intolerance, envy and often violence; it is no coincidence that these problems are foundational for socialism.
The fundamental issue that socialism has with liberty as Hayek noted is that “Liberty not only means that the individual has both the opportunity and the burden of choice; it also means that he must bear the consequences. Liberty and responsibility are inseparable.” It is understandable that children who lack these life skills will suffer from self-entitlement, a belief that they are owed whatever privilege and success others may have without the responsibility of earning it; this dependency on emotion rather than reason ignores the reality that coercion is required to have others provide this for them, or even worse to prevent others from achieving more than them.
This childish ideology we call socialism has been around long enough to provide the historical record of consistent failure simply because it was never about the creation of wealth, only the redistribution of it, requiring confiscation of what others have produced; this is its existential conflict with liberty. As we celebrate America’s 250th anniversary, we need to understand that it’s not about government or politics, but about us as a society, and that at its core society is about family and the children we raise and expect will grow to love and support liberty; this was not something we invented, but something discovered and expressed by many wise people long before we were country.
“Mankind is at its best when it is most free. This will be clear if we grasp the principle of liberty. We must recall that the basic principle is freedom of choice, which saying many have on their lips, but few in their minds.” Dante Alighieri
