“The most dangerous man to any government is the man who is able to think things out for himself, without regard to the prevailing superstitions and taboos. Almost inevitably he comes to the conclusion that the government he lives under is dishonest, insane, and intolerable.” H.L. Mencken
From the ancient Greeks we have “kleptocracy”, the name for governments ruled by corrupt leaders (kleptocrats) who abuse their power to exploit the citizen’s wealth for their own advantage and enrichment; this need not be done outside the law as laws can be created to facilitate the deception that it’s all in the cause of the greater good. Once such a cause is established under law, what remains is for the bureaucratic process to move the money along the path to where it can be used by those politicians who created those laws for their benefit.
It is not so much that Mencken is being cynical about the inevitability of such corruption, but observant both historically and regarding the current circumstances of his time; he lived through a very chaotic and transformative era in America from the end of the Great Frontier to the Cold War. While it was a period of huge economic development, it was also a period of wars, depressions, revolutions, and the growth of extreme political partisanship; in it all he saw the rise of statism, both home and abroad. What he also observed were the failures of “democracy” to preserve the liberties so essential for the health of the Republic.
The recent news hysteria about all the fraud being found in so many government welfare programs would not really have surprised Mencken because as a journalist, essayist, satirist, and cultural critic he had written and spoken often of the same problems of his time; what I believe may have shocked him is the magnitude and conspicuous nature of such corruption of our time. It’s not only the huge amounts of money involved in the cases found in Minnesota, California, etc., but the declared ignorance of the problem claimed by those responsible when in fact it was known to have been going on for some time.
There’s another word that comes down to us from the ancient Greeks, this about willful ignorance, i.e., agnotology; they saw this as a cultural or societal phenomenon where the ignorance of a people provides their leaders with the political tools to manipulate and deceive them. The most vulnerable are those that suffer from economic and financial illiteracy; it’s not an affliction limited to “developing countries” but prevalent in much of the so called developed western countries, in whose societies so many lack the knowledge necessary to make sound decisions about their personal finances or understand the economic consequences of their governments policies.
The common vehicle used by those that wish to deceive people about the corruption inherent in the nature of government welfare programs is the ignorance of the people themselves; when there’s opposition to such proposed laws, there is a default response mechanism we have come to know as “Virtue Signaling”, cloaking the self-righteous as advocating against racism, capitalism…or whatever label works to shame the opposition and avoid transparency. The unfortunate combination of ignorance about economics, finance, and virtue signaling is that all too often it actually works in favor of corruption…until it doesn’t!
Will Rogers once observed that “The United States Senate opens with a prayer and closes with an investigation.” When schemes such as those discovered in Minnesota, California, etc., are exposed, we get the scandals, the investigations, along with the obligatory and mind numbing endless news coverage, full of partisan posturing and “expert” analysis; what we never get is all that money back, accountability and an end to the policies and programs that caused these problems to begin with.
“Beware of altruism. It is based on self-deception, the root of all evil.” Robert A. Heinlein
